29 July 2010, 2:00 am
Inspired by what I thought was a biased answer to another question. I thought SURELY there are 20 better CHF's than Tredrea. Tredrea to me has been a massive disappointment - I thought he would be the greatest player of all time - now I think of him as "yeah he was OK at his best but what an ego" I must say my knowledge of WA and SA footy is limited and I'm sure there are better players than the following: Here's my list of 20 best ever CHF's, in rough order: Royce Hart (Richmond) Ted Whitten (Footscray) Dermott Brereton (Hawthorn) Steve Kernahan (Carlton) Laurie Nash (South Mel) Fred Flanagan (Geelong) Barry Robran (North Adelaide) Chris Grant (Footscray) Wayne Carey (North/Adelaide) Billy Brownless (Geelong) Adam Goodes (Sydney) Ron Clegg (South Melbourne) Terry Daniher (Essendon) Ross Glendinning (North/WC) George Moloney (Geelong) Bernie Quinlan (Fitzroy) Jack Worrall (Carlton) Jonathan Brown (Brisbane) Murray Weidemann (Collingwood) Jason McCartney (only AFL player I didn’t play on to make me cry so I put him in ahead of Tredrea) (I have to admit it was harder than I thought to exclude Tredrea - help me out here!) Yeth but bigguth, were they better in a thpot at thentre half forward?! Ok, yeth probably Longmire and Lowe definitely in (but Lowe was inconsistent which is one of my gripes with Tredders) Baldock - how did I miss him? He's in. Pavlich yet to prove himself - he looks like Tredrea in his second year. With Mathew Robran and Jimmy Hird in ... well Tredders is looking shaky now. And you couldn't leave either of them out. Peter Carey and Lindner I remember Kev. Didn't Lindner have a son or nephew played for Geelong (we got a lot of SA boys - "not quit Melbourne!") I meant *quite*... Read More »
Share on del.icio.us
Share on digg
Share on Technorati
Share on reddit
Share on Yahoo!
Share on Furl
